Is MAGA pro-Nazi?



This question arises quite often, perhaps more frequently than is comfortable, which suggests it’s an issue worth addressing seriously.

Elon Musk’s controversial gesture at Donald Trump’s inauguration, which some observers have interpreted as resembling a Nazi salute, undeniably adds weight to the argument that a segment of the MAGA (Make America Great Again) Movement harbors pro-Nazi sentiments.

The relationship between the MAGA movement and Nazi ideology is complex and controversial. While the MAGA movement itself does not explicitly endorse Nazism, there are concerning parallels and associations that historians and political analysts have noted.

Some experts have drawn comparisons between MAGA rhetoric and fascist ideologies such as 1) the emphasis on a cult of personality around a charismatic leader, 2) the promotion of ultranationalism and nativism, 3) the scapegoating of minority groups and immigrants, 4) claims of election fraud and betrayal by elites, and 5) use of intimidation and threats of violence against opponents.

The MAGA movement, like fascist regimes, has been accused of manipulating truth to suit its agenda. Trump’s unsubstantiated claims about the 2020 election echo Hitler’s narrative about Germany’s WWI defeat. Of course, MAGA rhetoric has been criticized for famously promoting a narrow view of American identity, often with undertones of racism and discrimination against minorities, immigrants, and certain religious groups.

Historian Ruth Ben-Ghiat has argued that Trump’s MAGA campaign centered on fascist visions of national rebirth.

And there have been instances of neo-Nazi and white supremacist groups expressing support for Trump and the MAGA movement. For example, the “Unite the Right” rally in Charlottesville in 2017 included Nazi imagery and slogans. Moreover, some MAGA supporters have been documented using Nazi salutes and symbols. Even convicted January 6 rioter Timothy Hale-Cusanelli, described by prosecutors as a “white supremacist and Nazi sympathizer,” attended Trump events.

President Trump, the face of the MAGA movement, has used language that echoes fascist rhetoric. He’s referred to opponents as “vermin” to be “rooted out” and has promised to “root out the communists, Marxists, fascists, and radical left thugs that live like vermin within the confines of our country.”

Historians have compared such statements to language used by Hitler and Mussolini.

While most folks involved with the MAGA movement probably don’t support Nazi ideologies, there appears to be a concerning level of tolerance towards such views compared to the rest of the population. It’s important to critically examine this dynamic and encourage a stronger stance against hate and extremism.

MAGA supporters and some Republican figures reject comparisons to Nazism. They argue the movement is about patriotism and traditional values, not extremism. Some absurdly claim that Nazis were actually leftists, though historians dispute this characterization. And for all it’s worth, Trump has denied associations with Nazi ideology.

While the MAGA movement is not explicitly pro-Nazi, there are concerning parallels in rhetoric and ideology, as well as instances of neo-Nazi support that have alarmed many observers. The movement’s relationship to fascist ideologies remains a subject of intense debate and scrutiny among scholars and the public.

Latest